A Section 125 plan is one of the few benefits where the employer usually comes out ahead on cash. The costs are small and mostly one-time; the payroll tax savings are recurring and scale with headcount. But “small” is not “free”, and the price depends on which kind of plan you set up. Here are the real ranges.
The three cost buckets
1. The plan document. A cafeteria plan must have a written plan document adopted before the plan starts. This is the piece you cannot skip. Typical pricing:
- Premium-only plan (POP) document from an online document provider: roughly $100 to $300, one-time, with $50 to $150 for updates when the law changes.
- Full cafeteria plan document with a health FSA or dependent care FSA: roughly $300 to $700 from a document provider, or included in a TPA’s administration fee.
- Custom document drafted by an ERISA attorney: $1,500 and up. Rarely needed for a small employer.
2. Administration. A POP needs almost none: payroll takes the deduction pre-tax and that is the administration. Plans with FSAs need someone to substantiate claims and handle reimbursements, usually a third-party administrator at about $4 to $7 per participant per month, often with a $50 to $100 monthly minimum.
3. Nondiscrimination testing. Required every year. Many TPAs include it; stand-alone testing runs about $150 to $500 per year. Some payroll providers include a basic test.
What is usually free
- Setting up the pre-tax deduction codes in Gusto, ADP, QuickBooks Payroll or Paychex. It is a standard deduction type.
- Employee enrollment forms, if you use the document provider’s templates.
- The employer’s FICA savings. There is no fee to claim them; they simply stop being withheld.
How the numbers compare
The employer saves its 7.65% FICA share on every dollar employees run through the plan pre-tax, plus any federal and most state unemployment tax on those amounts. Using Lumara Health’s figures published on this site, a typical program saves $600 to $1,100 per eligible employee per year.
| Company size | Annual cost (POP, document + testing) | Annual employer savings at $600/employee | Net |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 employees | about $300 to $500 | $6,000 | ~$5,500 |
| 25 employees | about $300 to $600 | $15,000 | ~$14,400 |
| 50 employees | about $400 to $800 | $30,000 | ~$29,200 |
With a health FSA added, administration adds roughly $50 to $350 per month depending on headcount, and the savings grow because employees run more dollars through the plan.
The costs people forget
- Time. Someone has to collect elections once a year and set up new hires. For a POP this is an hour at open enrollment and ten minutes per hire.
- Plan amendments. Each legal change (contribution limits move every year) can mean a document update. Budget one every two to three years.
- Correcting mistakes. The expensive scenario is not the plan, it is an owner who was enrolled when ineligible, or a missed nondiscrimination test. Both are cheap to prevent and annoying to unwind.
Where Lumara Health’s model differs
Lumara’s program bundles the Section 125 framework with a preventive care management plan and a self-insured medical reimbursement component, and its published position is no added cost to the employer or employees, with setup in 30 to 45 days. The economics come from the payroll tax savings funding the program. Whether that structure fits your company depends on your headcount and current benefits; the right first step is a savings estimate on your actual payroll, not a generic calculator.
Frequently asked questions
Is a Section 125 plan free to set up? No. At minimum you need a compliant plan document, which costs $100 to $700 depending on the plan type. Everything after that is optional depending on which benefits you include.
Can I write the plan document myself? You can adopt a template, but it must meet the Section 125 content requirements and be kept current. Most small employers buy a document from a provider or get one through their administrator rather than drafting from scratch.
Do the savings start immediately? Yes, on the first payroll after employees’ pre-tax elections take effect. There is no waiting period for the tax treatment once the plan is adopted and elections are in place.
Want a savings estimate on your real headcount rather than a table? Talk to Lumara Health and we will run it for you.
General information, not tax or legal advice. Price ranges are typical market figures as of 2025 and vary by provider.